On This Page
What Is Email A/B Testing?
A/B testing (or split testing) means sending two versions of an email that differ in one element to separate portions of your list, then comparing results to see which performs better. The winning version can then go to the rest of your list, and the lesson informs future emails.
Testing replaces guesswork with evidence about what your specific audience responds to.
What to A/B Test
| Element | Example Test | Measure With |
|---|---|---|
| Subject line | Question vs statement | Opens (with caution) and clicks |
| From name | Brand name vs person's name | Opens and clicks |
| Preview text | Benefit vs curiosity | Opens and clicks |
| Call to action | Button text or color | Clicks |
| Email length | Short vs detailed | Clicks and conversions |
| Format | Plain text vs designed | Clicks and conversions |
| Offer | Free shipping vs percentage off | Conversions and revenue |
| Send time | Morning vs evening | Clicks |
How to Run an Email A/B Test
- Write a hypothesis. "A benefit-focused subject line will get more clicks than a curiosity one."
- Change one element only, so you know what caused any difference.
- Choose the success metric before sending: clicks, conversions or revenue.
- Split your list randomly using your platform's split test feature.
- Use a large enough sample. Small lists produce noisy results.
- Wait long enough for most engagement to happen, often several hours to a day.
- Pick the winner and send it to the remainder if your platform supports it.
- Record the result and test again to confirm patterns.
A/B Testing with a Small List
If your list is small, splitting it into tiny groups produces unreliable results. Instead:
- Test bigger differences, such as two very different subject line styles.
- Run the same type of test across several sends and look for a consistent pattern.
- Focus on clicks rather than opens.
- Use tests to generate ideas, not final proof.
Testing Automated Emails
Automated sequences, such as welcome or cart emails, run continuously, so small improvements compound over time. Test one email in the sequence at a time, such as the first welcome email's subject line, and let it run long enough to collect meaningful results before changing anything else.
Reading Results Fairly
- Small differences may be chance. Repeat tests before drawing firm conclusions.
- Be careful with open rates, which privacy features inflate. Clicks are more reliable.
- Look at the full funnel. A subject line that gets more opens but fewer conversions is not a winner.
- Context matters. A result from a holiday promotion may not apply to a regular newsletter.
Built-In Split Testing
AWeber's paid plans include split testing so you can learn what your audience prefers.
Our #1 Autoresponder PickOn a tighter budget? See Moosend, our #2 pickA/B Testing Ideas to Try First
- Short subject line vs longer, more specific subject line
- Including a first name vs no personalization
- One call to action vs two links to the same page
- Plain-text style vs designed template
- Story-led opening vs direct offer
Subject line ideas: see our email subject lines guide. Metrics: see email marketing metrics.
Testing Landing Pages Too
Email tests improve clicks, but the page people land on decides conversions. Dedicated landing page builders such as Leadpages include page A/B testing on higher plans, which pairs well with email split tests.
Common A/B Testing Mistakes
- Testing several changes at once
- Declaring a winner too early
- Testing on very small samples
- Never applying what you learned
Testing landing pages too? Our landing page best practices guide covers what to test first.
A/B Testing FAQs
How Big Should My Test Groups Be?
Large enough to produce meaningful differences. With small lists, test across several sends and look for consistent patterns.
How Long Should an Email A/B Test Run?
Long enough for most subscribers to engage, often several hours to a day depending on your audience.
What Should I Test First?
Subject lines and calls to action are good starting points because they directly affect opens and clicks.
Does AWeber Offer A/B Testing?
Yes. AWeber includes split testing on its paid plans.
Start Split Testing Your Emails
AWeber includes split testing on paid plans, so you can test subject lines and content and send the winner.
Our #1 Autoresponder Pick